“Don’t be fooled. The only truly impressive aspect of this ‘Carmen’ is its Carmen: the 27-year-old mezzo-soprano Aigul Akhmetshina...Her molten yet agile tone can be confiding one moment and extroverted the next, and she moves with magnetic naturalness onstage.”
Read more

“ ‘Carmen’ can be bracing as well as seductive. The sparking currents of class and race are timely.”
Read more

"In the title role, the young Russian mezzo Aigul Akhmetshina had the vocal goods—a throaty, low sound with a hint of steel—and she didn’t overplay Carmen’s seductiveness, but her performance was low energy, lacking the character’s magnetism and seeming more acted upon than acting."
Read more

“...local audiences will probably have to live with this unilluminating ‘Carmen’ for another decade until the Met once again tries to pin down the eternally elusive gypsy.”
Read more

“Aigul Akhmetshina made a magnetic and often caustic ‘Carmen,’ her voice equally suited to silken lightness as leathery depth...Akhmetshina also gave ‘Carmen’ a restless physicality that never cut into her singing.”
Read more

“This ‘Carmen’ is one of the biggest disappointments I have experienced in a long time. Given the work’s preponderance in the repertory, it feels like new productions of something like ‘Carmen’ should either stray toward a safer but strong approach or go for broke with a sharp-cutting new concept that while polarizing, is artistically clear and successful.”
Read more

“Akhmetshina’s lyric mezzo-soprano is full bodied, rich, and supple. Its presence and clarity enables it to carry effortlessly into the theater. She dug deeply into the depths of Carmen’s psyche”
Read more