Two strangers on Fire Island discover they unknowingly dated the same boy as teens.
Two strangers unexpectedly cross paths and soon realize they dated the same boy as teenagers. As they share their stories, a series of flashbacks reveals how their relationships blossomed simultaneously, each unaware of the other's existence.
The parallel love stories unfold through these memories, highlighting the shared experiences and emotions that connected them in ways they never imagined. Based on a true story, this tale delves into the unexpected bonds that form from past connections.