"I'm Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire" explores the dynamics of para-social relationships and the explosive nature of obsessions. In this Y2K farce, a teenage girl named Shelby Hinkley navigates the challenges of adolescence in 2004. 

The storyline unfolds as Shelby's kidnap plot unravels, revealing deeper revelations that challenge the perception of Tobey Maguire as a mere heartthrob.

Dive into this comedic exploration of teenage infatuation, unveiling unexpected twists and turns in the pursuit of an idolized romance.