Eddie and Dave NYC Reviews and Tickets
Show-Score Member Reviews (54)
See it if You were a super fan of Van Halen
Don't see it if You don’t like to amateurish performances. Its only redeeming feature was the actor playing Valerie Bertinelli.
See it if you love 80's rock and Van Halen story in the form of a comedy skit with gender reversals. Fun elements and jokes.
Don't see it if you aren't into a comedy skit as it might not be for you. Similar to Wayne's World vibe but biography of the band.
See it if You're a Van Halen fan or just enjoy rock n' roll antics. You enjoy gender-bending castings.
Don't see it if You're out of touch with pop culture, don't enjoy rock n' roll references, would rather just see "My Fair Lady."
See it if you are intrigued by role-reversals.
Don't see it if You are against actors playing opposite genders.
See it if You’ve followed Van Halen over the years and would enjoy talented actresses acting out the highlights, with some recorded music & no singing
Don't see it if You haven’t followed the band’s antics. I would have preferred a mash-up of acting, videos, lip synching, to break up the story
See it if you're nostalgic for 1980s MTV culture, were a Van Halen or David Lee Roth fan, or enjoy weird quirky shows.
Don't see it if you don't like quirky plays which switch the gender roles of characters, have no interest in pop culture of 1980s, or want a serious play
See it if if you like this music, and great performances plus unusual staging
Don't see it if if you are not a fan of in fighting within rock groups
See it if You want to have a fun evening. I had no idea that this play was about, but I learned a lot about Van Halen, and laughed a lot.
Don't see it if You don’t like gender bending roles. The male roles are played by women and Valerie Bertinelli is played by a man. Read more
Critic Reviews (18)
“Larky if bloated sketch of a bio-comedy...Based on the original guitarist and lead singer of the chart-topping band Van Halen...The female cast members...appear to be having a high old time finding the testosterone within their characters’ teased hair...Initially, this is pretty funny...Ultimately, the comedy is too blunt and repetitive to sustain the 90 uninterrupted minutes...There is throughout a mind-bending glee in watching women taking on the extravagant guises of hot-dog rock ’n’ rollers.”
Read more
“Staats’s unabashedly goofy rock bioplay...Affection for music and the ridiculous past are the columns on which Staats has built her comedy...The music hews perilously close to Van Halen’s classic bangers...The attempts to take something that feels bootleg and turn it into something...leave the play a little muted. Thankfully, the gender-swapped performances go to 11...This big-hearted show sounds too much like an electric guitar—right before you plug it into the amp.”
Read more
"Staats has written a sincere but simple love letter, a cheerful act of fan fiction that bubbles along enjoyably enough without ever really becoming more than the sum of its parts...The twist...is that the boys...are all embodied by women...At times it’s great fun to watch the women...At other times, the cross-gender gambit leads to easy joke territory...There’s lots of good humor...but...there’s also not much there there...It’s striving for something bigger, but it never quite makes the Jump.”
Read more
“Staats invites her audience into a snow globe filled with glitter and cocaine to recount the heroic journey of the band Van Halen, resulting in 100 minutes that are indeed as magical as they are ridiculous...She straddles the line between Bertolt Brecht and Tennessee Williams, imparting wisdom while navigating the murky waters of memory.
And thanks to the committed performances of this five-person cast, we're willing to go along."
Read more
“Staat’s fun and frisky comedy...Women are scripted to play all the male music stars, a choice that makes the audience think about the role gender plays...Thurber does a great job of providing melodies that suggest classic tunes...But ‘Eddie and Dave’ doesn't appear to be a jukebox musical in the making. Its formidable strength is in the garage band attitude used to tell the age-old tale of how clashing egos can both create art and mess it all up.”
Read more
“Staats' new play may prove a pleasant diversion...Or you can stay home and watch Netflix...The spin Staats and Bordelon put on this story...Is that the men...are all portrayed by women...What's the point? It's a valid question that's only partially answered...which wears out its welcome...Casting women to play these men is...A fresh sensibility that allows us to see those characters in a new light. One just wishes Staats' characters were more interesting that they are in ‘Eddie and Dave’.”
Read more
“A spoofy treatment of rock musical band Van Halen...The switched gender ploy is cute as a Facebook puppy video for a while...But for all of the comedy’s 90 intermissionless minutes it’s not really a barrel of sustained laughs and chuckles...After about 20, maybe even 30 of those 90 minutes, we’ve seen enough of Staats’ guitar miming and Hill’s strutting as the full-of-himself Roth and Salem’s amusing go at femininity.”
Read more
“Staats’s hilarious, unexpectedly touching and altogether delightful reimagining of one of classic rock’s last, best epic rivalries...The gender twist is a clever conceit on a couple of levels; first, it allows...Bordelon and Hill to revel in the hirsute crooner’s diva-like qualities—also emphasized by the scrumptiously over-the-top, divinely tacky costumes...’Eddie and Dave’ is...a requiem for a bygone time, pre-reality TV...And before snark, which is refreshingly absent in this play.”
Read more