Set in Edmond, Oklahoma, Cooking With Butter is a musical that explores identity, sexuality, and growing up in a shifting social landscape. Inspired by a high school speech delivered during the 2020 presidential election, the story follows five students—Maggie, Kat, Tallie, Connor, and Daisie—as they navigate personal challenges and the complexities of adolescence.

United by a shared love of grilled cheese sandwiches, the group finds connection and comfort through food, music, and honest conversation. Their experiences reflect broader questions around belonging, self-expression, and societal pressure, all within the microcosm of their school and personal lives.

Blending moments of humor, chaos, and introspection, the show weaves together original music and a contemporary lens on queer theory, offering a layered look at youth identity and friendship in a divided time.